The KitchenAid Classic Stand Mixer delivers impressive performance, making it a reliable choice for home bakers. While it lacks some features found in the Artisan model, it's a fantastic option for those who want quality without breaking the bank. The smaller mixing bowl is perfectly sized for single loaves of bread or a cake, making it a great companion for family baking occasions.
Pros of the KitchenAid Classic Stand Mixer
-
+
Ideal size for average bakers
-
+
More affordable than many KitchenAid models
-
+
Attachments are dishwasher-safe
-
+
Outstanding whisking capability
-
+
Produces fantastic cakes
-
+
Kneading duration is flexible
Cons of the KitchenAid Classic Stand Mixer
-
-
Speed for bread dough is somewhat limited
-
-
No handle on the mixing bowl
-
-
Not designed for large batches
-
-
Limited color selections
Expert reviewers rigorously test and evaluate the latest kitchen products to assist you in making informed choices.
Having grown up using my mom's Empire Red KitchenAid, I have always had a fondness for these mixers. When selecting one for myself, I chose the KitchenAid Classic Stand Mixer over the Artisan model due to its affordability and compact size, perfect for my two-person apartment.
In my assessment of the KitchenAid Classic, I often find myself comparing it to the Artisan, which ranks highly in our best stand mixer recommendations. While the Classic may lack some conveniences, I would gladly choose it again to save that extra $100 while still enjoying quality mixing and its stylish presence in my kitchen.
KitchenAid Classic Stand Mixer Specifications
- Colors: black, white
- Type: tilt-head mixer
- Capacity: 4.5 quarts
- Weight: 22 pounds
- Speed settings: 5
- Material: stainless steel
- Dimensions: W8.7 x D14.1 x H13.9 inches
- Motor: 275 watts
- Attachments: dough hook, whisk, flat beater
As Head of Reviews, I enjoy testing kitchen appliances in my own home.
Having tried most of the stand mixers in our roundup, I can confidently compare the KitchenAid Classic to other leading models. I tested it in our kitchen before bringing it home for further evaluation to keep this review updated with my experiences.
Unboxing the Mixer
Though compact, the KitchenAid Classic weighs a solid 22 pounds. It arrived securely packaged in a large box with protective materials to ensure safe transport.
While I prefer recyclable packaging, I understand the necessity for sturdy materials to prevent damage during shipping. Plus, it proudly displays a 'Made in USA' label, indicating the durable quality you can expect from this product.
Included with the mixer are an extensive instruction manual, a wire whisk, a flat beater, and a dough hook. However, it lacks a splash guard, which I recommend purchasing separately, as the 4.5-quart bowl can create a mess when preparing larger quantities.
Making Cakes
Each baker has their signature recipe, and mine is a classic vanilla sandwich cake. It's simple yet reliable, serving as a benchmark for testing mixers. My straightforward recipe rarely fails, so if something doesn't turn out right, it's usually the fault of the mixer.
For the cake, I added all ingredients to the bowl and mixed at medium speed for a few minutes. While some sources claim the KitchenAid Classic has ten speeds, it actually has five, with each speed increasing in increments of two. So, if you set it to speed 4, it's just the second notch up.
It's common for mixers to leave flour or butter unmixed at the bottom of the bowl, necessitating a spatula to ensure everything is combined. Fortunately, this wasn't an issue with the KitchenAid Classic. While I did notice a few butter lumps upon transferring the batter into tins, I was pleasantly surprised by how well it mixed overall.
Pouring the batter into cake tins proved challenging due to the lack of a bowl handle, requiring me to tilt the bowl with one hand while scraping with the other. The final cake was delicious, so much so that there were no leftovers after our testing session. It had a light texture and baked evenly. Overall, this mixer excels at creating simple loaf or sandwich cakes.
Whipping Cream
A great test of any mixer is its ability to whip cream quickly. I prefer this light filling for my cakes, pairing well with jam to create a delightful slice.
With more powerful mixers, I can whip cream in under a minute, but the KitchenAid Classic, with its 275-watt motor, is on the lower end in terms of power.
While wattage might seem limiting, the build quality plays an essential role in performance. A sturdy mixer can deliver effective power despite a smaller motor, while weaker machines may shake and rattle during use, leading to frustration.
It took me 1 minute and 50 seconds to whip my cream to the desired consistency using a 6-speed setting. I was cautious about splashes, which made me aware of the absence of a splash guard—a feature my mom valued in her Artisan model.
Kneading Bread Dough
Kneading bread dough can be quite a challenge for stand mixers. It requires repeatedly working a solid ball of dough around the bowl, which can be too much for smaller models.
KitchenAid suggests not exceeding speed 2 for kneading on the Classic, which may extend the kneading time required to achieve the desired elasticity.
At first, the dough wrapped around the hook instead of being kneaded, but a stopper at the top of the hook prevented it from moving too far up. After five minutes, the dough had developed a good amount of elasticity, and after another five minutes, I let it rise before transferring it to a tin for baking.
The baked bread rose beautifully, with an excellent distribution of air pockets. While the KitchenAid Classic isn't suited for large batches, it's perfect for making a classic loaf or cinnamon rolls. Just remember to heed the speed recommendations, as I noticed it wobble when I increased the speed during kneading.
Cleaning the KitchenAid Classic
Cleaning is straightforward. The flat beater, dough hook, and bowl are dishwasher-safe, but the whisk must be cleaned by hand. I've learned this lesson the hard way.
To maintain the mixer's shine, wipe it down with cleaning spray after use. Just remember to rinse the bowl if it comes into contact with any cleaning solution.
Comparison with the Artisan
The primary competitor to the KitchenAid Classic is the KitchenAid Artisan. The Artisan offers additional features, including a larger 5-quart bowl and a handle, plus a wider selection of colors.
You can mix and match the Artisan with various bowls, including an ice cream maker and a glass bowl, while most attachments compatible with the Artisan will also work with the Classic.
After using both, I'd choose the Artisan if I had an extra $100 and wanted more color options. While it might seem trivial, the aesthetic appeal of a KitchenAid mixer is worth considering; it should be a joy to both use and display.
That said, the Classic fits in perfectly with my predominantly white kitchen and doesn't suffer from the smaller bowl size or motor. The main downside is the absence of a bowl handle, a reasonable trade-off for the price difference.
Should You Purchase the KitchenAid Classic Stand Mixer?
The KitchenAid Classic narrowly misses a five-star rating due to its handle-less bowl and lack of splash guard, which could complicate daily use and justify the investment in the Artisan model.
While the smaller motor might be a concern, it's perfectly adequate for the mixer's bowl capacity. The KitchenAid Classic may not be suited for commercial baking, but it's an excellent choice for home bakers wanting to fill the kitchen with delightful treats.
