When considering a new mattress, people often suggest taking your time to decide. A mattress sleep trial offers just that, allowing you to try out your bed for weeks or even months to see if it suits your needs. If it doesn't, returning it for a refund is typically straightforward.
Sleep trials can save you time and money when purchasing a mattress online. If visiting a showroom isn't feasible, these trials let you evaluate your mattress in the comfort of your home.
What You Should Know About Mattress Sleep Trials
To kick things off, it's helpful to clarify what a mattress sleep trial is. I consulted with various manufacturers and sleep experts to understand how these trials function and which brands provide the most favorable terms.
Defining a Mattress Sleep Trial

A mattress sleep trial is a designated timeframe established by the manufacturer, allowing you to test the mattress in your home before finalizing your purchase.
Lori MacLachlan from Sleep Number emphasizes the importance of this trial: 'A mattress trial is essential when you're buying a new bed. If it doesn't work for you, returning or exchanging it is hassle-free. Many retailers provide extensive trial periods and return policies, so pay attention when shopping.'
She points out that 'Sleep Number offers a 100-night trial for their smart beds, enabling you to assess if it's the right choice.' If the mattress isn't meeting your expectations, reach out to the manufacturer for a refund. They may ask for feedback to recommend a mattress type that better fits your needs.
From my perspective as a mattress tester, 100 nights is sufficient to evaluate a bed across different seasons, particularly its temperature regulation. If you need more time to decide, seek out brands offering longer trial periods, with some providing up to 365 nights for thorough testing.
Benefits of a Mattress Sleep Trial

One of the standout advantages of online mattress shopping is the sleep trial. Instead of just testing a mattress for a few minutes in-store, you have the chance to experience it over weeks and months, giving you a clearer picture of how it fits into your sleep routine.
The longer the trial, the more comprehensive your testing can be. During evaluations, we score each mattress based on comfort, support, breathability, motion isolation, edge support, and price. Testing each bed over several months allows us to understand its performance relative to our individual sleep needs.
Best on Test
Saatva Classic Mattress
Among all the mattresses we've evaluated, the Saatva Classic Mattress stands out as the best. Our expert tester, Jaclyn, awarded it high marks for comfort, cooling, and value. Experience it yourself with Saatva's 365-night trial.
Explore more in our Saatva Classic Mattress review.
Pressure Relief
Nectar Memory Foam Mattress
Casey, one of our testers, finds relief from fibromyalgia with the Nectar Memory Foam Mattress, noting it alleviates pressure on her joints.
Discover more in our Nectar Memory Foam Mattress review.
Flexible Support
DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress
This hybrid mattress accommodates all sleep positions and fits various budgets. Despite being labeled 'luxury,' it remains affordable, featuring a memory foam top for plush comfort and an innerspring core for better airflow.
Find more details in our DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid Mattress review.
Drawbacks of a Mattress Sleep Trial

A common misconception is that mattress sleep trials allow you to try the mattress without upfront payment. You'll need to pay initially, and refunds are only available if you return the mattress within the specified period. Always read the terms and conditions carefully, as some brands may require you to use a mattress protector to qualify for a return.
Not all brands refund the full amount after a trial. For instance, Saatva deducts a $99 shipping fee, while Nectar charges for their White Glove service and state recycling fees. Reviewing the terms before purchasing is crucial.
Many brands offer free accessories like sheets or pillows, but these may not be included in the trial terms. If you return the mattress, the cost of these items could be deducted from your refund.
Andy Bloom, a mattress salesman, highlights the practical aspects: 'Some companies will pick up the mattress, while others might require you to ship it back. Return policies vary widely, so understanding the specific terms is essential before buying.' He adds that although the intention is good, mattress trials often lead to higher consumer costs due to handling and disposal expenses.
Additionally, returning a mattress can have environmental consequences, as many mattresses end up in landfills, taking years to decompose. If sustainability is a priority, seek out brands that recycle or donate old mattresses.
Mattress Sleep Trials FAQs
What to Observe During Your Sleep Trial?
Monitor Your Sleep Changes: The ideal mattress should provide a balance of comfort and support, helping you stay cool and alleviating aches.
Watch for Aches and Pains: A suitable mattress should relieve discomfort within a few weeks. New aches are normal initially, but persistent pain may indicate the mattress is too soft or firm.
Assess Quality: Within the first months, a good mattress should show minimal signs of wear. It should feel softer while still appearing and functioning like a new product.
Can You End a Mattress Trial Anytime?
No, most brands require you to adhere to a minimum trial period, usually around 30 days, allowing enough time to adjust to a new mattress.
Final Thoughts
When buying a new mattress, carefully review the warranty terms. Don't get swayed by extravagant lifetime guarantees; instead, look for sensible coverage against defects in materials and manufacturing.